|A) JYK 12L||B) JXK 12I|
|C) JXX 12L||D) JXK 12L|
The four women seem to agree that the plate starts out with the letter J. Three of them agree that the plate ends with 12L. Three of them think that the second letter is X, and a different three think that the third letter is K. The plate description that has all of these common elements is D.